Search site
Call our office
Make an enquiry
Our Resolve. Your Resolution.
When a loved one dies, emotions often run high and in today’s world of second families, step-relationships, and unmarried partners, disagreements over an estate can quickly turn into formal disputes.
This is especially true where the estate is substantial, involving property, land, business assets or significant investments, and where expectations differ from what is set out in the will or trust.
Our probate dispute solicitors specialise in resolving disputes over high-value, complex estates. We act for clients across the country, with many of our instructions coming from North and East Yorkshire, where we can offer in-person meetings at our offices in York and surrounding towns.
Our team of contentious probate solicitors is led by Simon Black, a registered member of the Association of Contentious Trust and Probate Specialists (ACTAPS). Clients and peers have praised his work:
“Simon Black… thoroughly on top of his file and prepared to go the extra mile for his clients. A hugely persuasive force at mediation and precisely the kind of lawyer you would want in your corner.” The Legal 500, 2025 Edition
“Responsive, efficient, no-nonsense approach. Works incredibly hard, thinks outside the box, and delivers.” The Legal 500, 2023 Edition
This depth of knowledge and practical, determined approach runs throughout our team, which includes experienced litigation partners Richard Hugill and Paul Burkinshaw, enabling us to protect our clients’ interests in even the most complex cases.
Our contentious probate solicitors on all aspects of probate disputes, including:
Our contentious probate solicitors provide dedicated pages exploring some of the most common and complex situations our clients face:
Can a step-child contest a will? – Understanding the legal grounds, family dynamics, and strategic considerations in step-family inheritance disputes.
Business probate disputes – Protecting value and resolving conflicts when company shares, commercial property, or partnership interests are part of an estate.
Farm probate disputes – Navigating disputes over agricultural land, farm businesses, and generational inheritance expectations.
Proprietary estoppel claims – Pursuing or defending claims where promises of inheritance of property, land, or businesses were relied on but not honoured.
Challenging an executor – Advising beneficiaries and executors alike where questions arise over estate administration, executor duties, or potential removal.
These pages provide further detail on the unique challenges of each type of dispute and how we can help.
A will can be contested if it fails to meet strict legal requirements. Common grounds include:
If you were financially dependent on the deceased and the will (or intestacy rules) does not make reasonable provision for you, you may have a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Our probate dispute solicitors regularly bring and defend such claims, often involving substantial property and investment portfolios.
Where promises about future inheritance are made and relied upon, for example, contributing to the upkeep or improvement of a property or business, we can pursue or defend claims based on proprietary estoppel, promissory estoppel, or constructive trust principles.
For more detail, see our dedicated page on Proprietary Estoppel Claims.
Executors and trustees must act in the best interests of the estate or trust and its beneficiaries. Disputes can arise over:
Where necessary, we can seek removal or replacement of executors or trustees or defend against such applications.
For further guidance, see our page on Challenging an Executor.
Where no will exists, the intestacy rules determine who inherits. This can lead to disputes, especially where there is uncertainty over who should act as administrator or how assets, particularly high-value or illiquid ones, should be divided.
We offer various funding options to assist you obtain the justice you seek. In addition to the traditional 'pay as you go' hourly rates, we consider:
All cases are assessed individually and funding options discussed with you to determine which would be most suitable.
Although many disputes do still proceed to court or arbitration, we recognise that clients' interests are often served in seeking to resolve disputes in other ways outside the court process. This can resolve disputes much more quickly and at significantly reduced cost. Mediation is a recognised alternative to litigation. To find out more about the various options available, go to Courts & Alternative Dispute Resolution.
Our probate dispute solicitors can arrange meetings at any of our local offices in York and across Yorkshire, so simply contact your nearest Harrowells office in York, St Saviourgate, Clifton Moor, Easingwold, Haxby, Pocklington, Malton, and Thirsk.
Over the Christmas and New Year holiday season all our offices will be closed at 1pm on Wednesday 24th December 2025 and then reopen on Monday 5th January 2026. The details of each day as shown below: Tuesday 23rd December -...
Christmas is a time for giving, and many of us like to treat our loved ones to something special. Most gifts are simple enough, but bigger or more valuable presents can come with tax implications that are easy to miss. Knowing the rules means you can give...
How the Employment Rights Bill will affect zero hours, casual and agency work
Following the government’s announcement of the new Employment Rights Bill, which is expected to come into force in April next year, this is the fourth instalment in our five-part blog series exploring the key changes to expect. In this post, we focus...
